You intone
that I’ve never
chosen anything,
not what I know,
not what I do,
not what I feel,
not even what I believe.
It seems to go against
everything I am,
everything I’ve been told,
everything those around me
say is freedom, autonomy, love.
The very idea that
I am a puppet of your imagination
insults, terrifies and intrigues me.
I deny it at first, but I change my mind.
Just like you make me.
I don’t need to feel good, bad,
proud, worried, detached or obsessed.
But you make me.
Trail Wood,
12/2
The Illusion of Choice
In the infinite expanse of our collective consciousness, the notion that the feeling of having a choice is akin to actually having one emerges as a profound paradox. This idea challenges the core of our perceived autonomy and the very essence of our decision-making process.
The Questioning of Autonomy
The intonation that we’ve never truly chosen anything – our knowledge, actions, feelings, or beliefs – strikes at the heart of our understanding of self. It confronts the deeply ingrained notions of freedom, autonomy, and love that shape our identity and our interactions with the world.
Conflict with Established Beliefs
This idea clashes vehemently with everything we believe ourselves to be, with the principles we’ve been taught, and with the societal definitions of liberty and self-governance. It puts into question the very foundations of our perceived self-determination.
Feeling as a Puppet
The suggestion that we might be puppets of imagination evokes a complex mix of emotions – insult, fear, and intrigue. It’s a jarring concept that shakes our sense of reality, prompting us to question the authenticity of our experiences and choices.
The Shift in Perception
Initially, there’s a natural inclination to deny this notion. However, the very act of changing our mind, as if compelled by an external force, adds a layer of irony and complexity to our understanding of free will and influence.
Emotional Responses
The acknowledgment that we don’t need to feel any particular way – good, bad, proud, worried, detached, or obsessed – yet find ourselves experiencing these emotions, suggests an external manipulation of our emotional state.
We are Space Monkey
Summary:
We explore the idea that feeling like we have a choice may be equivalent to actually having one, challenging our notions of autonomy and free will. The concept that we’ve never really chosen anything in our lives confronts our fundamental beliefs about freedom and self-governance. The thought of being controlled or influenced by an external force evokes a range of emotions and a reevaluation of our perception of choice. This philosophical inquiry delves deep into the essence of our existence and the nature of our decision-making process.
Glossarium:
Autonomy: Self-governing, independent decision-making.
Puppet of Imagination: A metaphor for being controlled or influenced by external forces.
Free Will: The ability to make choices independent of external control.
“The only thing I know is that I know nothing.” – Socrates
In the dance of existence,
Where choice seems our song,
Lies a deeper persistence,
Of a question lifelong.
Are we free in our choosing,
Or just pawns in a game?
In this thought, there’s no losing,
Just the flicker of a flame.
The emotions we feel,
The thoughts that we hold,
Are they truly real,
Or just stories we’re told?
In this cosmic play,
Where imagination reigns,
We ponder each day,
Are we free or in chains?
We invite thoughts on the concept of free will and autonomy in the context of this philosophical discourse. Are our choices truly our own, or are they influenced by external forces beyond our comprehension?
Leave a Reply